Volume 30, Issue 5 (8-2023)
RJMS 2023, 30(5): 211-220 |
Back to browse issues page
Research code: 01
Ethics code: IR.IAU.SARI.REC.1401.195
Clinical trials code: 01
Download citation:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:
BibTeX | RIS | EndNote | Medlars | ProCite | Reference Manager | RefWorks
Send citation to:
Safari A, Hosseini Moghadam S A, Arab Khazaili A. Simulation Techniques in Medical Sciences with a Legal Approach. RJMS 2023; 30 (5) :211-220
URL: http://rjms.iums.ac.ir/article-1-7828-en.html
URL: http://rjms.iums.ac.ir/article-1-7828-en.html
Assistant Professor, Department of Islamic Law and Jurisprudence, Sari Branch, Islamic Azad University, Sari, Iran , dhoseini@gmail.com
Abstract: (459 Views)
Background & Aims: The effort of scientists to control and treat diseases opens new horizons for human society every day. The cloning that has been successful in the case of plants and animals, on the one hand, has fueled enormous challenges and fundamental questions about human cloning, and on the other hand, it has promised to cure many diseases. The goal of cloning therapy is to create stem cells that are similar to the patient's stem cells. The purpose of this will not be the production of a human being, but it is meant to restore life and full health to a person, to be allowed to achieve it. In this context, prominent statements and their opponents and supporters have explained their views. Therapeutic simulation is one of the challenging issues of the contemporary world, but no comprehensive and extensive research has been done on this issue. Cloning, which is another name, comes from the root of clone, which is a Greek word, and its literal meaning is "sprouting and multiplying". Cloning in biological science means "reproduction of a living organism without sexual intercourse" and currently refers to the act of implanting an embryo in the womb that was first produced in a laboratory. The cell is a French word that means that living organisms, despite the differences in shape and characteristics, are all made of small elements called cells, whose structure is almost the same in animals and plants. The meaning of cell in Farsi is "cell" which means a living organism despite the difference in shape and appearance. The process of asexual production of a group of cells, molecules, or living organisms that are all genetically similar is called "simulation" or "cloning". The different uses of this word indicate a common element, which is: the creation and production of a creature similar to the original animal without the involvement of the sexual element. Hence, cloning can be translated into asexual reproduction. Cloning means the steps that are taken to produce several copies of a single gene, and this term is used to mean the physical separation of a single cell and its multiplication in the culture medium to produce a population of those cells. In short, the production of an individual or a group of individuals that are genetically identical to what has been reproduced is called cloning. The most complete form of simulation is somatic cell nuclear transfer through which simulation takes place. By using this technique, the nuclear materials of the human somatic cell or the donor are transferred into an egg that has already been deactivated. Finally, it stimulates the formed egg cell to start its growth and development stages, and as a result, a cloned embryo is obtained. On the other hand, one of the new legal issues is the issue of simulation. This technique is one of the achievements and challenging issues of the contemporary world, but it has also been faced by scholars of jurisprudence, lawyers, and authors of legal texts. Accordingly, this article was conducted with the aim of investigating and analyzing simulation techniques in medical sciences with a legal approach.
Methods: This descriptive-analytical study analyzed and described its sayings and ideas with the method of documentary studies. In this method, the simulation process is carried out by splitting the embryo. Explanation that one or more cells are taken from the fertilized embryo and placed in a suitable environment such as the uterus or a laboratory tube. Each of these cells has the ability to turn into a new embryo, the result of which, if placed in a suitable space, is an embryo like the original embryo. This method is the same way that happens in nature, and identical twins or multiple twins are considered to be a manifestation of it. This method has been successfully used on many animals such as sheep, cows, mice and monkeys.
Results: The results of the research indicate that the therapeutic simulation of the dual process is carried out by the method of embryo derivation and nuclear transfer, and healthy cells are replaced by defective and unhealthy cells, the purpose of which is the possibility of restoring life and health to a person, on the other hand, techniques Infertility treatment such as in vitro fertilization, sperm injection into the uterus is one of the methods commonly known as assisted reproductive methods. From the point of view of its goals, simulation is classified into two types: human or reproductive (first paragraph) and research or therapeutic (second paragraph). In other words, simulation is done for two purposes: creating a perfect human (human simulation); Creating different organs of the human body (therapeutic simulation). The realization of the second goal is in such a way that every potential cell has the ability to become all the cells of the organs, so the growth can be stopped in the laboratory and only a specific cell, such as the heart, nerve or kidney, etc., can be allowed to grow. gave There are many disagreements and oppositions regarding human cloning due to its negative consequences, but there is no disagreement among scientists regarding therapeutic simulation, and even because of its widespread use and its many and important benefits in medicine, it is welcomed because of the treatment of chronic diseases.
Conclusion: In this paper, the simulation technique, which is considered one of the new human achievements, was discussed, and in this regard, the desired approach was expressed from the perspective of the jurists of the Imamiyya school and Iranian law writers. And it is the subject of controversy in the contemporary world, which has entered into the field of writing with the aim of researching, examining, and explaining the jurisprudence and legal ruling of therapeutic simulation technique, and the writer has tried to analyze and describe the material using the library method. The findings of the research indicate that, first, its therapeutic application is to create stem cells that are similar to the patient's stem cells, in this type of simulation, healthy cells are replaced by defective and unhealthy cells; in the continuation of the discussion, we concluded that the simulation phenomenon takes place during the dual process by two methods of embryo derivation and nuclear transfer. In addition, infertility treatment techniques such as in vitro fertilization, sperm injection into the uterus, and other methods are commonly known as assisted reproductive methods. The results of the research show that from the point of view of its goals, simulation is divided into two types of human or reproduction or reproduction (first paragraph) and research or therapeutic (second paragraph) and with the two goals of creating a complete human (human simulation) and creating different organs of the human body (therapeutic simulation) is done that in the legal discussion of this issue, we can pay attention to the following: abortion has a customary meaning and the custom of destroying laboratory embryos is not considered abortion. Also, the analogy of "Mustanbat al-Ala" is not valid in Imami jurisprudence, and the ruling on abortion and the destruction of the fetus outside the womb cannot be considered the same. On the other hand, the similarity of the principle of innocence, if we have doubts about whether something is haram, we rule that it is not haram. The rule of Daraa also stipulates that in case of doubt, punishment cannot be carried out. Therefore, there is no reason to prohibit the destruction of the simulated embryo, and it seems that extracting and using stem cells from it is without problems.
Methods: This descriptive-analytical study analyzed and described its sayings and ideas with the method of documentary studies. In this method, the simulation process is carried out by splitting the embryo. Explanation that one or more cells are taken from the fertilized embryo and placed in a suitable environment such as the uterus or a laboratory tube. Each of these cells has the ability to turn into a new embryo, the result of which, if placed in a suitable space, is an embryo like the original embryo. This method is the same way that happens in nature, and identical twins or multiple twins are considered to be a manifestation of it. This method has been successfully used on many animals such as sheep, cows, mice and monkeys.
Results: The results of the research indicate that the therapeutic simulation of the dual process is carried out by the method of embryo derivation and nuclear transfer, and healthy cells are replaced by defective and unhealthy cells, the purpose of which is the possibility of restoring life and health to a person, on the other hand, techniques Infertility treatment such as in vitro fertilization, sperm injection into the uterus is one of the methods commonly known as assisted reproductive methods. From the point of view of its goals, simulation is classified into two types: human or reproductive (first paragraph) and research or therapeutic (second paragraph). In other words, simulation is done for two purposes: creating a perfect human (human simulation); Creating different organs of the human body (therapeutic simulation). The realization of the second goal is in such a way that every potential cell has the ability to become all the cells of the organs, so the growth can be stopped in the laboratory and only a specific cell, such as the heart, nerve or kidney, etc., can be allowed to grow. gave There are many disagreements and oppositions regarding human cloning due to its negative consequences, but there is no disagreement among scientists regarding therapeutic simulation, and even because of its widespread use and its many and important benefits in medicine, it is welcomed because of the treatment of chronic diseases.
Conclusion: In this paper, the simulation technique, which is considered one of the new human achievements, was discussed, and in this regard, the desired approach was expressed from the perspective of the jurists of the Imamiyya school and Iranian law writers. And it is the subject of controversy in the contemporary world, which has entered into the field of writing with the aim of researching, examining, and explaining the jurisprudence and legal ruling of therapeutic simulation technique, and the writer has tried to analyze and describe the material using the library method. The findings of the research indicate that, first, its therapeutic application is to create stem cells that are similar to the patient's stem cells, in this type of simulation, healthy cells are replaced by defective and unhealthy cells; in the continuation of the discussion, we concluded that the simulation phenomenon takes place during the dual process by two methods of embryo derivation and nuclear transfer. In addition, infertility treatment techniques such as in vitro fertilization, sperm injection into the uterus, and other methods are commonly known as assisted reproductive methods. The results of the research show that from the point of view of its goals, simulation is divided into two types of human or reproduction or reproduction (first paragraph) and research or therapeutic (second paragraph) and with the two goals of creating a complete human (human simulation) and creating different organs of the human body (therapeutic simulation) is done that in the legal discussion of this issue, we can pay attention to the following: abortion has a customary meaning and the custom of destroying laboratory embryos is not considered abortion. Also, the analogy of "Mustanbat al-Ala" is not valid in Imami jurisprudence, and the ruling on abortion and the destruction of the fetus outside the womb cannot be considered the same. On the other hand, the similarity of the principle of innocence, if we have doubts about whether something is haram, we rule that it is not haram. The rule of Daraa also stipulates that in case of doubt, punishment cannot be carried out. Therefore, there is no reason to prohibit the destruction of the simulated embryo, and it seems that extracting and using stem cells from it is without problems.
Type of Study: Research |
Subject:
Clinical Psychiatry
Send email to the article author
| Rights and permissions | |
 |
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License. |
